This is a summation of
the views of local residents on a proposal to build
a children's residential unit at Queen's Terrace,
Maybole which they are sending to South Ayrshire
Council. They are continuing to distribute the
consultation feedback forms and would like to remind
everyone that the consultation ends on April 30. One
person at the public meeting said he moved out of Coylton because of problems at the unit there and he
said he couldn't put up with it.
Roads
Queens Terrace is a
1950s housing estate with narrow roads. The Council
removed a row of garages to allow access to this
area of land and there are now cars parked on the
pavement in this area. Additional traffic will
increase the danger to the many young children who
live in this area.
Children
This is an area with
young families and the residential unit is not a
suitable environment for the many young children who
play in this area. We do not know who will be
staying in this unit and they will be allowed access
to the local area and the young children who live in
the area. There is a play area at the top of the
hill and parents may be reluctant to allow their
children to use that.
Property Values
Many of us in this
area have purchased our properties, at the
encouragement of the Council. Positioning a unit in
the middle of an already established community will
only push our property prices down.
Social problems
Close to the proposed
unit is the largest estate in the town which has a
history of social behavioural problems.. Council
staff and the local police have been involved in
many of these problems and you should be aware of
them. Acts of vandalism, violence amongst
neighbouring youths, drug dealing and fire-raising
are among a history of disorder. This unit will be
a magnet for local troublemakers. Why has no social
impact assessment been carried out in relation to
this proposal?
Police
The additional demands
on the police can only make it more difficult for
them to continue to do their jobs. The reported
call-outs to the Coylton residential unit will
continue and the Maybole unit will simply add to the
time taken dealing with the problems.
Call out figures for
Coylton as far as we understand the situation are:
1/4/2008 - 31/3/2009 -
111 calls to the Police
1/4/2009 - 31/3/2010 -
158 calls to the Police
Why would you put a
second unit in the same police area? This would
appear to us to be a completely irrational decision
and we are simply stunned that the Council are even
considering this.
Maybole was the
location of a residential school for 35 years until
the Council closed it approximately four years ago.
We feel that the town has carried its share of the
burden and the Council should be looking for a site
to the north, probably in the Ayr/Prestwick/Troon
areas, where the majority of the residents come
from.
Consultation on
Children’s Home at Queen’s Terrace, Maybole
Following the recent
public meeting held in Maybole Town Hall on
Wednesday March 3 Maybole Community has a few
questions it wanted to raise with South Ayrshire
Council.
A letter was sent off
and last week community councillors met to consider
the reply. They also agreed to hold a meeting with
anyone concerned about the development to discuss
the way forward. This will be held in the Town Hall
on Monday April 12 at 7.30pm.
Q1 - Over the past
year, what is the numbers and percentage of children
in child care residential units from all wards
The figures over the
past 12 months show 55% of children accommodated
were from Ayr, 30% were from Prestwick and Troon and
15% were from Kyle and Carrick. The principle of
maintaining familial and educational connections
linked to a South Ayrshire community remains true.
Ayr and Troon are still being pursued. Girvan is not
given the increased expense of transporting children
to their local school/area.
Q2 – It was mentioned
that the children would be educated in their
existing schools. Why is it proposed to place them
in Maybole which, for the majority, will be some
distance from their schools? How do the children get
to school? Are the children escorted?
Maybole offers a
community with good public transport links that can
enable young people, where appropriate, to travel
independently to schools and services in other
localities.
Those young people
unable to travel independently will (as with other
young people within South Ayrshire living at home
with parents) be transported to/from school or their
educational base.
Q3 – What are the
amenities in Maybole for these children in the
evenings and weekends? There are not enough
facilities our own young people never mind
youngsters with special needs.
It is not anticipated
that 6 young people will only utilise Maybole
resources or facilities. They will all have
individual needs, and interests and have individual
plans. Some of this will be facilitated by
care/support staff, which will support young people
to access appropriate leisure and recreational
opportunities, either in the local area or elsewhere
dependent on the activity. These could include
uniform organisations, youth clubs and leisure
facilities/clubs.
Q4 – Can we have a
full list of ALL Council owned land and a full list
of all the sites that were considered and ALL the
reasons for rejecting them?
· TARBOLTON,
James Street – after investigation the community was
considered too small.
· AYR, Open
Space at Caledonia Road – ruled out on Planning
Grounds following consultation with Planning
Service.
· AYR, Open
Space at Hayhill - ruled out on Planning Grounds
following consultation with Planning Service.
· MAYBOLE
Queens Terrace – possible site for construction from
technical and operational perspectives. No planning
issues and no issues with other services who would
be consulted through the Planning process. Ayrshire
Housing outline planning consent for the site not
any constraint on Council’s ability to develop the
site. Site investigation reports are positive.
· AYR Dunlop
Terrace - possible site for construction from
technical and operational perspectives. No planning
issues and no issues with other services who would
be consulted through the Planning process. Site
investigation reports are positive.
· TROON,
Buchan Road is currently, as agreed under
re-consideration. Established that a Unit will fit
on this site. No site investigation has been
undertaken and no view has been sought from the
Planning Service although this will happen.
· DUNDONALD,
site of former David Lane Centre – initially
Dundonald was not felt to be a suitable site for
development due size of community – this will be
re-investigated.
· Several
other sites in Ayr were considered. However, these
are all in Lochside, Whitletts and Dalmilling and
have been ruled out due to location being close to
areas where most young people who are accommodated
live.
· Sites south
of Maybole were not to be considered as the
associated costs to maintain family/educational
links would increase greatly.
· An updated
list of ALL Council owned sites is being developed
and will be made available. Many of these are
unsuitable for a number of reasons including
location, size and existing use.
· Bill Gray
and Hugh Carswell are continuing to look at
alternative sites.
Q5 – At the public
consultation meeting, the Councils representatives
kept repeating that the Maybole site was preferred
because it “answered all our needs”. What is it
about this site that is so special compared to all
the other Council owned sites?
The primary issues
which make Maybole suitable are: ownership; size of
site; accessibility to site; that it is in a
community of a reasonable size; it provides ready
access to infrastructure which will allow young
people to access South Ayrshire facilities and their
local communities and the site has permission for
residential development which would allow the unit
to be fully integrated.
Q6 – At the
consultative meeting a council representative said
that the plans for the units had been prepared
in-house. Can we have it confirmed in writing that
the plans were not prepared by a private firm?
The response was
incorrect. Whilst the plans for the units were
commissioned by the Council they were drawn up by
local architects firm, Robert Potter and Partners.
The designs have been
agreed after a series of research visits to other
authorities and consultation with Looked After young
people.
Q7 – There are rumours
in the town that contracts for the unit in Maybole
have already been sent out for tender. Can we have
it confirmed in writing that this is not the case?
No contracts for the
unit at Maybole have been issued.
Q8 – Obviously over a
period of time, South Ayrshire Council must have
known the lifespan of the home at Coylton, so why
not do something a bit sooner rather than waiting?
The new Directorate of
Children and Community requested investment in the
residential estate within its first year of
operation in order to take a strategic approach to
allowing young people to be accommodated locally and
reducing the associated cost to South Ayrshire
Council.
Q9 – Why does the
Council mix disruptive children with mainstream
children in schools?
South Ayrshire Council
has a policy of inclusion for all children and young
people, based on assessed needs. However where a
child’s needs are best met in a specialist
placement, South Ayrshire Council facilitates this.
This is in line with
national policy initiatives and research which
indicates that children and young people are best
supported where possible in a mainstream setting.
This is supported by a
range of additional school-based and
centrally-managed resources as well as external
placements.
Q10 – Can the Council
not open up the consultation with no early closing
date, why the rush to close the consultation?
Following further
discussion between the Executive Director, Community
Council and Ward Elected Members the consultation
period will run until the end of April.
CAIRN PRIMARY
SCHOOL’S HEALTHY FORTNIGHT
“Everyone at Cairn
Primary School had a happy, healthy, fun
fortnight leading up to the Easter holidays.!
Activities varied
from interactive dance mat boogies to
Teambuilding activities with Active Schools.
Every class took a turn at making a healthy
snack for the whole school and each day was
filled with lots of exciting opportunities to be
fit and healthy. The fantastic football Fantasia
on Thursday rounded off the fortnight with all
staff and pupils taking part in the event.
Huge thanks to all
our helpers for making Health Fortnight such a
success and ensuring all our pupils learned lots
about keeping themselves fit and well, ready for
the Summer term!”
A special thanks
to the following individuals and groups for
their kind support during Health Fortnight:
Alison Jones,
School Nurse;
Tracey Capstick
and her Team, Cairn School Kitchen
Active Schools
Coordinators, Jill Tomlinson and Ryan Douglas;
Brian Jamieson and
the Community Wardens;
Liz Kennedy,
colleagues and staff, Somerfield Supermarket,
Maybole;
Damien Kelly, Ayr
Rugby Club;
The girls from the
Carrick Coach Academy;
Mr Scott Anderson,
Maybole Golf Club
Mr McKay of J.R.
Watson Butchers, Maybole;
Mr McKay from
Mountain Rescue;
Angela McDonald
from NHS Oral Health Team;
William Ferguson
and John Cairns, Ayr College;
The Jumpstart
Team, NHS Ayrshire & Arran
Drongan Health
Initiative for lending their fabulous Dance Mats
We couldn’t have
done it without you all – many, many thanks.
Event 1 - Boys
Pr.5 Breaststroke
1 Jack Broun
(GE)
2 Scott
Jackson (CL)
3 Ryan
Maxwell (CN)
4 Darra
Murdoch (SC)
Event 2 - Girls Pr.5
Breaststroke
1 Heather
Thom (KL)
2 Leah De Mey
(MT)
3 Phoebe
Young (CN)
4 Emma
Baillie (GE)
Event 3 - Boys Pr.6
Breaststroke
1 Liam
Cuthbert (CN)
2 Scott
Jackson (CL)
3 Ryan Smith
(MT)
4 Ewan
Campbell (GE)
Event 4 - Girls Pr.6
Breaststroke
1 Heather
Thom (KL)
2 Rebecca
Campbell (SC)
3 Vicki Green
(GE)
4 Louisa
Davidson (MT)
Event 5 - Boys Pr. 7
Breaststroke
1 Ryan
Jackson (CL)
2 Liam
Cuthbert (CN)
3 Ronan
McDowall (SC)
4 Liam Wyllie
(GE)
Event 6 - Girls Pr. 7
Breaststroke
1 Phoebe
Maitland (CL)
2 Ciera
Campbell (SC)
3 Rosie De
Mey (MT)
4 Ellis Bird
(KL)
Event 7 - Boys Pr.5
Backstroke
1 Scott
Jackson (CL)
2 Jack
Connelly (CN)
3 Reece Adams
(GE)
4 Aidan
McQuillan (SC)
Event 8 - Girls Pr.5
Backstroke
1 Katie
Eccles (GE)
2 Leah De Mey
(MT)
3 Cara
Mundell (KL)
4 Laura Paton
(SN)
Event 9 - Boys Pr. 6
Backstroke
1 Kieran Robb
(CN)
2 Scott
Jackson (CL)
3 Ryan Smith
(MT)
4 Ryan Speirs
(GE)
Event 10 Girls Pr. 6
Backstroke
1 Rebecca
Campbell (SC)
2 Hannah
McSorley (GE)
3 Laura Paton
(SN)
4 Phoebe
Young (CN)
Event 11 Boys Pr.7
Backstroke
1 James
MacAulay (GE)
2 Ryan
Jackson (CL)
3 Kieran Robb
(CN)
4 Ryan Smith
(MT)
Event 12 Girls Pr.7
Backstroke
1 Phoebe
Maitland (CL)
2 Rebecca
Graham (CN)
3 Rosie De
Mey (MT)
4 Courtney
Blane (GE)
Event 13 Boys Pr.5
Freestyle
1 Scott
Jackson (CL)
2 Ryan Harrop
(GE)
3 Austin Wise
(SN)
4 Ryan
Maxwell (CN)
Event 14 Girls Pr.5
Freestyle
1 Heather
Thom (KL)
2 Phoebe
Young (CN)
3 Xsara
Meiklem (GE)
4 Macy Racle
(MT)
Event 15 Boys Pr.6
Freestyle
1 Liam
Cuthbert (CN)
2 Kyle Ward
(GE)
3 Scott
Jackson (CL)
4 Ryan Smith
(MT)
Event 16 Girls Pr.6
Freestyle
1 Jacqui
Gibson (GE)
2 Rebecca
Campbell (SC)
3 Rebecca
Cameron (CL)
4 Kayley
Campbell (CN)
Event 17 Boys Pr.7
Freestyle
1 James
MacAulay (GE)
2 Ryan
Jackson (CL)
3 Kieran Robb
(CN)
4 John Limond
(KL)
Event 18 Girls Pr.7
Freestyle
1 Phoebe
Maitland (CL)
2 Jodie
Brownlie (SC)
3 Amy Graham
(CN)
4 Helen
McNair (KL)
Event 19 Boys Relay 4
x 25m
1 Gardenrose
2 Cairn
3 St.
Cuthberts
Event 20 Girls Relay 4
x 25m
1 Gardenrose
2 Cairn
3 Kirkmichael
Results for the opening night, 5th of April, 9 hole
non handicap
Nett Score
1. Colin McIlwraith - 35.5
2. Kevin Nibloe - 36
3. John Wood - 36.5
4. Scott Campbell - 38
Gary Steele
6. Gavin Campbell - 38.5
7. Ramsay Eccles - 39
8. Billy Bissett - 39.5
9. Kevin McKeown - 41.5
Kevin Doyle
Robert Green
12. Drew Ferguson - 42.5
Tom Foster
14. C. Hutchison - 46.5
15. Kevin Ward - NR
Scott Anderson